Understanding Movement in Diagnosis
An essential part of any clinical evaluation is manual diagnosis which, unfortunately, is often the missing element in modern medical practice. Many physicians today rely heavily on imaging, such as MRI, CT scans, or X-rays, which provide valuable but static information. These tests can reveal structural changes, but they do not show how the body moves, compensates, or adapts.
The human body is dynamic, not static. It breathes, bends, twists, and constantly adjusts to gravity and motion. Patients often describe their pain with phrases such as:
If pain appears only during movement, how can we diagnose it using motionless images? The only way is through movement itself - through touch, perception, and manual testing. That is why manual diagnosis is indispensable.
Treating the Cause, Not the Symptom
While conventional medicine often focuses on symptom management, osteopathic manual therapy seeks to understand and address the cause, the underlying dysfunction that produces those symptoms. This approach allows the practitioner not only to see where it hurts, but to discover why it hurts.
The practitioner must devote a great deal of attention to this process because accurate diagnosis is the foundation of effective treatment. When we can precisely identify the structure that reproduces the patient’s pain, sometimes even temporarily recreating the familiar headache or discomfort, we can work directly on the source.
For example, when a patient says, “My head hurts and my doctor diagnosed me with migraine,” that statement is far too general. The cervical region alone may cover approximately 12 inches (30 cm) in height and 6 inches (15 cm) in width. To locate the exact origin of pain, a manual evaluation must be performed.
Manual diagnosis includes assessment of both bony structures and soft tissues. Bones and muscles are living, elastic and mobile structures that respond to stress, posture and adaptation.
The first step is to orient yourself to the bony framework by sensing the alignment, asymmetry
and restrictions in motion. Through this living dialogue of touch and movement, the therapist
begins to perceive what no image can show: the functional truth behind the patient’s pain.
Case Story: Helen - When the Body Speaks Through Movement
The following case illustrates how manual diagnosis can reveal what imaging cannot. Helen came to me with years of headaches. She had been to many doctors and specialists and had a full set of test results from MRI, CT scans, and X-rays all showing there was nothing wrong. Yet the pain was real. It was there every morning, and sometimes was so strong that she couldn’t think clearly.
Helen told me, “It hurts behind my right eye.”
When I began the manual diagnosis, I gently tested each level of her neck. At the junction between C1 and C2, I felt resistance; the motion stopped early. The tissues in the entire neck area were tight and resistant, as if the body was guarding something even though she had no neck pain. When doing manual palpation, I was able for a very short moment to reproduce the same headache symptoms she described. She quietly said, “That’s exactly it. That’s the pain I feel
every day.”
At that moment, we both knew the body had shown us the cause. It wasn’t hidden in the scan; it was hidden in the movement. I worked gently on that small area, releasing tension and allowing the tissues to move freely again. When Helen stood up, she looked surprised and said, “It feels lighter… like the pain is gone.”
A week later, she called to say that she had been headache-free for the first time in years. That experience stayed with me. It reminded me that true diagnosis lives in motion, in what we can feel with our hands. Every patient’s body speaks; we just have to learn how to listen.
Through movement we discover the story the body has been trying to tell us all along. The hands can often see what the eyes cannot.
181 Waukegan Road, Suite 103, Northfield, IL 60093